Showing posts with label shelters. Show all posts
Showing posts with label shelters. Show all posts

Monday, May 17, 2010

Hoarders - why?

There are those people that are called hoarders. Among rescue people these individuals are seen as the most evil of people, comparable often times with animal abusers and murderers.

Lets take a look at the mentality that makes up a hoarder. A hoarder is a person that takes in animals and continues to take in more and more often times with no limit in sight. Their houses are over-run with dogs, cats, and whatever else. These people continue to take in more animals even though they are unable to care for the animals they have in a way that is acceptable by our standards. Most of the time this compulsion is triggered by several factors, namely in an effort to keep these animals from being killed at shelters. Hoarders are not collectors (who may have a “collection” of one type of dog or a particular animal), but instead take any and all animals. It’s not uncommon to see a hoarder with dogs, cats, and horses among other animals.

A hoarders goal starts out very noble and somewhere goes awry. They start out with 2, 3 or 4 animals and begin amassing more and more. Often times they try to adopt out the animals they have, but these efforts get squashed as the toll of taking care of their current animals takes up too much of their time. Their number grow by people dropping off animals to them, they get them from the shelters, strays find their way to the hoarders property and just about any other way to get animals, they get them. As it is very obvious to understand, without a major staff, it is impossible to care for but only a few animals. Hoarders don’t see the crazy cycle of neglect that is cast upon the animals, as their main goal is to keep the animals alive. They clearly see one vision: these animals would all be killed at a shelter. This forces us to look at a scary logic, is it better to have these animals living in somewhat deplorable conditions or kill them at the shelter? There are those who think that killing an animal (or as they refer to it- euthanizing) is a humane thing to do. I can only cite very-very rare occasions in which ending an animals life is a humane thing to do.

Although I do not agree with hoarders, I do understand their twisted logic or I should say, where their hearts lie. These people are animal lovers, they are trying to provide for the animals and save them, but the mission goes wrong somewhere. When the levy finally breaks and the amount of animals attracts enough attention, rescue groups and animal control agencies will step in. At this moment all efforts are shifted toward one thing: saving these animals from these deplorable conditions: although I ask the question, “Where were these people before?” What happens to these animals now is where the true demented logic comes in. For the most part they are taken to rescue organizations which are already over-run with too many animals, they are take to shelters which are also over-run with too many animals and the rest are killed / euthanized because of their conditions. The hoarder will go to jail, serve some time, pay a fine and eventually be free to start the same cycle again.

Ask most people in rescue if they had a million dollars what would they do with that money and I can assure you most will tell you that they would buy a big piece of property and take in as many animals as possible. These are the same people that abhor hoarders; at their core they are the same people. At their core they see the goodness, yet are unaware of the pitfall.

Are hoarders bad people? Are they abusers? I would say NO. The goodness of the mission goes wrong along the way and they get caught in the middle of a whirlwind that can’t be righted. These people started out with the goal of saving animals from the hands of those that will kill them, eventually only to be judged and condemned by these very people. Their animals are not properly cared for mainly because of a lack of resources. It should be noted that hoarders, for the most part, spend all of their money on the animals they have. These people are not living high on the hog in one house with these animals being abused and neglected somewhere else. Quite the contrary, these people live in the very same deplorable conditions that the animals under care live in. This indication alone shows me that these people are no more animal abusers, as they are human abusers because of the abuse they subject themselves to. They deny themselves the luxuries of life and instead live in sub-human conditions with the animals they are trying to save.

When the rescue community steps in, it is generally with a whirlwind of excitement, media attention and accusations hurled against someone who is not that far removed from the people casting the stones. Here is someone whose initial goals started out quite aligned with his or her own. These people step in and start taking the animals one by one, starting out with the ones that can be adopted and eventually ending up at the feral ones that no one can touch. These animals are generally on a short list to be killed.

I’d be a hypocrite if I only laid blame without a solution. And, perhaps my “solution” is less of a solution than an ideal that can be seen as nothing more than a dream. Since these people started out doing the work that all of us in rescue see as “kind of” the right idea that somewhere went wrong, how hard would it be to step in and help these people with some resources and support. What if their homes could be rebuilt to clean them up, some donations could be gathered to help with food and supplies and rescue organizations worked with them to help them adopt their animals out to homes? What if some people volunteered some time to keep this type of “no-kill shelter” rolling? What if our efforts would be geared at helping instead of hurting?

Instead people see these places as a dumping ground for dogs that they’ve been stuck with. Rescue needs to take a good hard look at themselves and understand that if someone is trying to do the right thing, they deserve some help. Throwing a person under the train does nothing to help the animals they’ve tried to help. As humans we are afraid to stand up for someone when it becomes un-popular, it’s easier to cast a stone than to ask people to put their stones down and try and do something.

If hoarders are such evil people, we need to define when they turn evil and what makes them evil. Is it when they have more than 10 animals, 20, 50 or 100? If they suddenly become evil at that point, why don’t people step in then and help? Is the act of evil that they are keeping these animals from being destroyed at shelters? Is the act of evil that they take these animals from people who drop them off to them, who tie them to their fences or even throw them over those very fences? Is evil living in deplorable conditions along with the animals in their care? As rescue we need to step up and help those who are helping, we need to work together. And, when one of our own is prosecuted, we should step up to help. I am in no way condoning hoarders or hoarding, but I am inviting you to look at that what makes hoarding what it is. We live in a country where we kill millions of animals every year. It’s done in a back room at the end of a hallway. We all know the room is there, but we choose to ignore it. If getting an animal out of a shelter gives it a chance at life, is it better to do that or kill it? It’s a perplexing question and one that we have to ask. If you were given the option to live in sub-standard conditions or face death, what would you choose? Personally I don’t know many dogs who live the life of the dogs that my closest friends have, but yet they live. Are we to judge what is good enough, and play G-d?

Robert Cabral
Bound Angels

Thursday, July 10, 2008

The Breeder - Your Friend

I probably have less of a problem with breeders than some people in rescue, but there is still an underlying issue that needs to be addressed.  So long as there are 5 million shelter animals dying in shelters, why do breeders continue?  The biggest problem with breeders is that most are not checked out, which means you are dealing with a potential of puppy mill breeders, which I do have a major problem with.  Puppy mills should be shut down and the owners of these places should be put in prison as child abusers are.  

I received a phone call from a woman the other day, which made me think to write this post.  She was referred to me by a local animal control officer.  She is having a problem with her Italian Mastiff.  Shall we guess what the problem is?  Aggression.  No kidding.  The lady explained that she took the dog to training, but the dog is not responding and has bitten the son and shows signs of aggression toward her.  For those of you who have not read my dog training blog or site, I invite you to go to www.blackbeltdogtraining.com and educate yourselves with what I face regularly from people who can not control their dogs. 

Mastiffs are a very strong and powerful breed.  These are the kind of dogs that when they turn, they will do a lot of damage.  And believe me, dogs will turn.  Why?  Because they are dogs.  Its not as big of a deal when your cocker spaniel turns on you, but when your 150lb mastiff turns, you have a bit of a problem.  You can't take a dog like this to your local pet store for training,  this requires someone who understands aggressive breeds.  And the best time to start training a dog like this is in the puppy stage, and never stop.  A dog like this, or any larger dog (or any dog for that matter), should be brought up to understand pack structure.  Unfortunately most people don't understand this themselves.  They think the dog is cute when its a puppy, but it grows up.

So, back to my point about the breeder.  I'm not slamming all breeders here, but I am slamming the one who sold this dog to this lady..  as well as the person who would be stupid enough to bring a dog like this home with no idea or research of the dogs characteristic.  Since the dog turned aggressive, he has to be put down or sent to a sanctuary.  Did the breeder offer to take the dog back? NO.   Did the breeder offer to send it to a sanctuary?  NO.  So what happens?  The dog gets murdered.  Why?  For being a dog.  The dog has the least fault in all of this.  The dog is being a dog.  Dogs get aggressive when there is a break in pack leadership.  This is what they do to protect the pack and themselves.  Please read more of my opinions on my Black Belt Dog Training site.  All I want to address here is that every time people don't think, an innocent dog dies.  This dog does not deserve to die, he should have never been brought into a home like this.  Obviously many breeders do not qualify the home for the dogs, as long as the check clears.   That is BULL&$%).  The breeder is responsible.  Rescues check out the potential homes for most all dogs they place, almost to a fault.  There is no special license people need to get a dog, in fact you can walk into any shelter or pet store and just take one home.  If it doesn't work out, its even easier, just drop them back at the shelter, and they'll kill them for you.  

Please educate yourself and the people you know that an animal is a life, to some of us it is as important as a human life.  At the very least, it is entitled to a chance at a happy life.  Animals that are turned into shelters for aggression need special attention, they can be rehabilitated, it takes work.  Before you get a dog that has dominant tendencies, educate yourself about the potential and what you need to know of the dog.  You'll be doing yourself and the animal a huge favor.

Saturday, April 26, 2008

The Rescue of May


It was a few weeks ago that the email came across my desk about May the “aggressive Sharpei” at the local animal shelter. The very next day I went down to see the little killer, all 30 something pounds of her. She was alone in a kennel, and cowered in the back. When the kennel attendant went in to get her, she crouched in the corner, tail between her legs, and yes, she bared her teeth. Once noosed (the term used to get a rope around a dogs neck to lead them out of the kennel), she was a little reluctant to come out.



Lets backtrack a little. We don’t know her whole history, as it is against animal shelter policy to disclose the event that led to the incarceration of the animal. I did find out that she was adopted to a person through a “rescue” and was then dumped at the shelter by the person who adopted her because “she tried to escape from their yard.” Remember, most of the time people will make up an excuse to give up a dog so they don’t look bad. Personally I’ve never met a dog that doesn’t have the urge to try and get away. Dogs like to run and play and don’t like confinement much. However, my point in all this is to look at the background of what we know of a dog. At 2 years old she’s been pushed around at least 3 times, and ended up in a shelter.

When dogs end up in shelters they often develop kennel syndrome, a condition that makes them go either very submissive or aggressive. It’s a tough place, much like a human jail, only worse: These “criminals” did nothing wrong and are more likely to die than get out.

Back to May. I led May to the “get acquainted” area and released her from her rope, let her run around a bit, do her duties and observed her. Within a few minutes she had her tail up. I approached her and touched her, played with her and soon afterwards, was able to rub her ears, head and legs… all trouble areas for an aggressive dog. I asked the kennel staff to reevaluate her and they said they would. She would be taken off of the “Red List.” May was safe. I would begin networking her for adoption and move on to other dogs to save. No more than a week later I received and email on a Friday that May would be killed on Sunday for aggression. I was floored. Nothing I could do to change the plan, May would die. Over my dead body. I sprung into action, called my good friend Melanie from Bark Avenue LA, and with her help I pulled May out of the shelter. I would need to board her until I could find her a forever home. I boarded her locally and asked everyone for donations. People pulled through. I would take May for regular walks and emailed, called, begged and pleaded for a home and funds for May. This went on close to 2 weeks. I took her to the beach, shopping and anywhere I thought I would find her a home. Several came forth, but none were just right for her. May had several good possibilities, but many fell through, others I didn’t like. Oh yeah, and about her aggression, it would become very obvious as she would sit in the back seat of my car and step up on the center console, rest her head on my shoulder and lick me while I was driving.

Last week I went to a party and took May with me. Many loved her, but one guy stood out when he met May. She took to him and he took to her. I thought it might be a good fit. Chris and I talked and emailed. I knew it would work just great. Wednesday April 23, I drive May to her forever home. Chris just adores her and the same holds true for May. In the two weeks I’ve been watching her, I never saw her roll onto her back, and within 10 minutes with Chris she was rolling on her backs and he was giving her belly rubs. It’s a match made in heaven. It just took some time and money… and if that’s not worth it to save a life, then nothing is.

Another happy ending. Thanks to everyone who helped….

Wednesday, April 9, 2008

The Current Rescue


Instead of backtracking, which I might do in the future, let me tell you about my current rescue.  She is a young lady named May, a 2 year old Chinese Shar Pei.  I met her at the local animal shelter.  I don't need to say which one, as I will try to curb my tongue, at least this week.  May was redlisted (which means the animal has less than 7 days to live), because of aggression.  I've seen this before, so I asked if I could re-evaluate her.  She was a bit shy and skittish when the worker pulled her out of her 4 foot x 8 foot kennel.  Once she was out, I took the lead and walked her to the "Get Acquainted Yard."  A place where the dog and person can interact.  This interaction is greatly disturbed in our shelters because of the fear energy and barking that is going on all around.  However, I did proceed with my evaluation.  She ran around a bit, then came up to me.  Within 5 minutes I was rubbing her head, grabbing her legs and playing with her with no signs of aggression WHATSOEVER...  

In either case, we were able to re-list her on the GreenList.  Which clears the animal from being killed.... kind of.  She was fine, and  began to network her to people via email for possible adoption.  I went in to visit her a few times, all seemed well.  

On Friday April 4th 2008 I got an email that May would be killed on Sunday April 6th.  I had one day.  The reason for her murder??  Overcrowding I was told.  I'll get into overcrowding at some future point, however, it was due to something else.  Lets stay with this part right now, which is May.  I immediately contacted my friend Melanie and asked if she would help me get May out.  She did and I sprung May. 

I picked her up form the vets where she was spayed.  To see her little tail wagging as she ran toward me brought a warmth to my heart that only a parent could feel when their child accomplishes something great...  For May that accomplishment was LIFE.  She made it out alive (unlike the MILLIONS who don't).  She immediately started licking me and her tail was going wild.  VERY AGGRESSIVE.  I put her in the backseat of my car and we drove off.  

Her underlying aggression could not be hidden for too long however.  Within minutes she jumped up on the center console and began an immediate assault on the side of my face - WITH HER TONGUE.  May is the Happy Sharpei I have met --- possibly ever.  

I have raised donations to cover her boarding for the better part of 10 days, and I'm optimistic that I will find a loving human that would deserve this much love, not sure if one exists.  I will keep you posted on May.  She loves walks, loves to ride in the car, gets on well with other dogs and has the fiercest tongue you could imagine....  

If you'd like to donate towards May, or toward the cause of Animal Rescue, please visit:

Thanks for reading and caring.

Robert
BOUND ANGELS